virsaviya (_virsaviya_) wrote in duo_lims,
virsaviya
_virsaviya_
duo_lims

Challenge 03 Round 09 Results

I'm so sorry, but we have to say "goodbye" to one participant.

Eliminated:


by ofraindrops 
(-3 votes)


People's Choice:


by ksi_liv 
(+4 votes)

Mod's Choice:

(Absolutely agree with the voters.)


So, our finalists are:
dance_the_dance, ksi_liv, loving_w
Congratulations!


Voting Tally (set number here):

01| -1
02| +4
03| -1+1=0
04| -1-1+1-1-1=-3



Lesser quality sets:

set # 1 - the texture on the 2nd icon doesn't fit the "mood" of the whole set at all, at least on the first icon there is need in something special that could decorate it

set #3 - the coloring really looks alike in both icons, plus the cropping in icon2 is a bit off

set #4 - bad text and crops
set #4 - simple coloring, text(1 icon) doesn't look good
set #4 - pale colorings, in the 1st icon the hair slightly greenish...and in the seond the white space looks strange
set #4 - Second icon is too blurry, letters "a" and "e" are out of icon, that isn't good,firsat icon - bad text placement.


Favourite sets:

set #2 - great colors, crop.. simple but really nice
set #2 - lovely coloring on icon1 & great use of b&w and contrast in icon2set
#2 - the coloring of #1 is very nice and soft, and the B/W of #2 looks very elegant
set #2 - Good colors.

set #3 - nice coloring

set #4 - lovely use of the text and good choice of the font which fit the set really good at all, nice colors and use of textures

Tags: results, round 3, round 3: challenge 9
Subscribe

  • (no subject)

    Hello, everyone! I'm the new maintainer of this comm (thanks to the lovely hel_lansky). Although it's been over a year since the last…

  • Challenge themes poll

    Hey, people!:) Did you miss us?:) New sign up will be posted soon. But now we should choose a new topic for our 4th challenge. Please, vote for the…

  • Extension

    I wanted to say, that one of our finalists ask to extend this round in order to participate in it)) I decided to wait some time)) So the final round…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 0 comments